Skip to main content

Qualities of a Good Leader - Parashat Miketz 5776 - December 11, 2015

The last few parshiyot of Sefer Beresheit present us with two potential leaders of b'nei yisrael - Reuven and Yehuda. Reuven was the first born - the bechor - and could have merited both the double portion of inheritance and the kingship. However, both mantles of leadership were given to other brothers. The double portion went to Yosef and his two sons, Ephraim and Menashe. Yehuda merited the Jewish kingship. Reuven became another one of the tribes.

In this week’s parasha, Miketz, the Torah presents a pivotal moment in the development of Ya’akov’s opinion of his sons, Reuven and Yehuda. The moment is a bellwether for their future standing as respective leaders of k’lal yisrael. The brothers return to their father’s house from their search for food in Egypt. Yosef – still an anonymous viceroy in the eyes of the brothers – has demanded to keep Shimon as ransom until the brothers’ return with their youngest brother, Binyamin. Reuven initially asks his father Ya’akov to send Binyamin with him to Egypt and he promises to safeguard his return. Reuven says to his father, “You will kill my two sons if I do not bring him (Binyamin) back to you; deliver him to my hand and I will bring him back to you.” Ya’akov’s response was sharp and decisive. He says, “My son will not go down with you.” After some time passed and the famine grew unbearable, Yehuda approaches Ya’akov. Yehuda says, “Send the young boy with me and we will get up and go so that we can live and not die – both us and you and also our little ones. I will be the assurance for him; of my hand you will demand him. If I do not bring him to you and set him before you then I will bear the blame forever…” Yaakov’s response was decisive – he sent Binyamin under Yehuda’s guardianship.

Interestingly, Reuven’s pledge is criticized by our Rabbis. In relation to this episode, the Midrash calls Reuven bechor shot'e – foolish firstborn. The Midrash elaborates - when people would say something worthwhile in front of Rebbi Tarfon, Rebbi Tarfon used to say kaftor va’ferach - buttons and flowers – a reference to the adornments that decorated the menorah in the mishkan. When people would say something meaningless in front of him, Ribbi Tarfon used to say lo yered beni imachem – my son will not descend with you – a reference to Jacob’s response to Reuven’s offer to take Binyamin to Egypt to retrieve Shimon.

Why did our Rabbis consider Reuven’s offer so inferior to that of Yehuda? Furthermore, why do our Rabbis look at Reuven’s offer to his father Jacob with such disdain?

I will identify three critical elements which bolstered Yehuda’s argument and dashed Reuven’s chances of leading the brothers back to Egypt with Binyamin in tow.

  • Past results. One important measure of a leader is past behavior. Reuven had previously sinned against Yaakov by meddling in Yaakov’s relationship with Leah and Bilhah. Yehuda had a history of strength of leadership. (See Ramban) 
  • Collateral offered. Reuven pledged his two sons and offered for Ya’akov to kill his two sons if Binyamin was not returned. Yehuda pledged that not bringing back Binyamin would constitute a sin. Reuven’s pledge was whimsical. Yehuda’s was serious. (See Ha’emek Davar) 
  • Timing. Taking Binyamin was an enormous risk. Shimon’s safety was already in doubt but there was no risk to Binyamin. Taking Binyamin would not guarantee Shimon’s safety – rather it would only expose Binyamin. Yehuda’s offer came after the threat to Binyamin had come in the form of a famine. (See Rashi) 
Reuven was well-intentioned. However, his impetuousness interfered in his ability to lead and effectively execute a plan. For this reason, Ya’akov did not trust him with the mantle of leadership for the family. Yehuda was a chacham – a wise man. Ya’akov determined that he could be counted on as an effective leader.

Shabbat Shalom.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Vows Compromise Our Free Will - Parshat Vayetze 5776 - November 20, 2015

At the opening of this week’s parasha , Vayetze, Ya’akov is leaving eretz Yisrael to find refuge in Charan from his brother, Esav. He arrives at HaMakom – The Place – to sleep for the night – the place of Ya’akov’s famous ladder dream. Morning comes. Yaakov takes the stone that he slept on, makes a monument to Hashem with it and anoints it with oil. He renames the place Beit E-l – House of Hashem. The Torah then records that Ya’akov made a neder – a vow. “If the Lord will be with me and will guard me on this path that I am going and will give me bread to eat and clothes to wear and will return me in peace to the house of my father … then I will give one-tenth of all that I have to Hashem.” At first glance, the fact that Ya’akov made a vow seems inappropriate. In general, the Torah looks down on vows. Our chachamim say noder nikra cho’te – one who makes a vow is treated like a sinner. What is wrong with making a vow? Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch explains that at worst a vow elevates tr...

Project Exodus

Mrs. Shelley Kutliroff, Morah Anat Kampf and Rabbi Moshe Nachbar (not shown) are leading the Junior High School students in Project Exodus with additional guidance from Talya Tsuna and Dr. Whitney Kennon. Project Exodus is a project of and is being funded by a grant from The Jewish Community Partners. The Junior High Students at the Margolin Hebrew Academy will be studying the history of the Jews from the Former Soviet Union via interviews with many local Jewish immigrants from the FSU. Project Exodus is an attempt to permanently document and archive the experiences of Jewish immigrants to Memphis from the former Soviet Union. This project is the inspiration of Lynne Mirvis.

Responding to Disaster in Baton Rouge - Parashat Ki Tavo 5776 - September 23, 2016

This has been a unique week for the students of the Feinstone Yeshiva of the South! In a normal week, two presentations – one by Rabbi Dovid Lieberman on the topic of Free Will and another by Ambassador Yoram Ettinger on the topic of supporting the State of Israel – would have been momentous. But this was no ordinary week. Our students – Cooper Yeshiva on Sunday/Monday and Goldie Margolin on Wednesday/Thursday – partnered with Nechama-Jewish Response to Disaster in providing disaster relief to three families who suffered catastrophic loss during last month’s floods in Baton Rouge, LA. Our students hauled damaged personal effects to the curb. They removed damaged drywall, flooring, paneling and appliances. They removed many, many nails. Our students worked very hard. As a chaperone for each of these two trips (CYHSB and GMSG), I saw the students witnessing destruction first-hand. The scenes were sobering. We saw block after block of homes devoid of life – families gone and the guts of t...