Skip to main content

When Good is Done to You, Acknowledge It! - Shabbat Chanukah-Parashat Miketz 5778

Our chachamim, in masechet Kiddushin, teach a general halachic principle: mitzvot aseh she'haz'man gerama nashim peturot – women are exempt from positive, time-dependent commandments. Generally, women may perform, but are not obligated to perform, those commandments that become obligatory only at a defined time. For example, the holiday of Sukkot occurs on the fifteenth day of the month of Tishre. The mitzvah of lulav is obligatory only during Sukkot. Since this mitzvah is time-dependent – it can only be performed during a specific window of time, women are exempt. Of course, should a woman choose to perform the mitzvah of lulav she may do so and it rewarded for doing so.

This Shabbat we celebrate the fourth day of Chanukah – chag ha’oorim. As is well-known, on each night of Chanukah we light a set number of candles corresponding to the number of nights of Chanukah that have elapsed. On the fourth night of Chanukah, we light four candles. Clearly, the mitzvah of Chanukah candles is time-dependent. Based on the explanation above, women would be exempt from Chanukah candles.

However, our chachamim teach that women are not exempt from Chanukah candles – women are, in fact, obligated. The Talmud teaches that there is a subset of positive, time-bound commandments which form an exception to the general principle presented above – those commandments which are connected to a miracle in which women were involved. In the language of the Talmud – af hen hayu be’oto haness – even women were in the miracle. Because women were involved in the miracle of Hashem saving the Jews from the hands of the Syrian-Greeks, women are obligated to light Chanukah candles. The Talmud gives an identical explanation for the obligation of women in the Megilah reading on Purim.

(As an interesting aside, including this exception, and other exceptions which are not within the scope of this presentation, to the category of positive, time-bound commandments, there are more exceptions to the rule than mitzvot that are consistent with the rule.)

Our commentators discuss the boundaries of the principle of af hen hayu be’oto haness. On the surface, it is not clear why women should be obligated to perform positive, time-bound commandments on the basis that women in history had been involved in the miracle that the mitzvah commemorates. Why is it not sufficient for males, acting as representatives of the Jewish People, as a nation, to be responsible for fulfilling the mitzvah? Furthermore, the description of the exception – even women were in the miracle – is difficult to understand. What is the meaning of the word, “even”?

Tosephot, based on Rashi, explain that af hen hayu be’oto haness means that women were saved by the miracle. Haman plotted to kill all of the Jews. The women, together with men and children, were saved by Hashem’s intervention. The Syrian-Greeks intended to forcibly convert all Jews and Hashem saved all of the Jewish People. Tosefot explain that it would be non-sensical for women to be exempt from these commandments – being saved from destruction requires praise, thanks and recognition of the event. If only a subset of the Jewish People had been miraculously rescued then it might make sense for a subset of the Jewish People to acknowledge the miracle. However, if each and every Jew experienced the miracle, each and every Jew must acknowledge the miracle and give praise and thanks. Even the women were saved, therefore, even the women must participate in the commemoration.

The concept that undergirds af hen hayu be’oto haness is connected to fundamental Jewish concepts such as hakarat hatov – recognizing the good that others do on our behalf – and Kiddush HaShem – publicizing G-d’s name and oneness to those around us. When it comes to these fundamentals, others cannot act on our behalf. Therefore, it would be insufficient for the only some representatives of the Jewish People to acknowledge the good that Hashem did. Each one of us must personally engage the opportunity to publicize Hashem’s Name and to thank Him the good that He has done on our behalf. On Chanukah, through personally fulfilling the mitzvah of Chanukah candles, each one of us engages in Kiddush Hashem and hakarat hatov.

Considering this concept more universally, each one of us should look for opportunities to personally engage in publicizing Hashem’s great Name and to personally recognize those great things that others do on our behalf. Through this personal engagement, we make an indelible imprint on our own philosophy and on the world around us.

Shabbat Shalom and Chanukah Sameach.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Honor and Glory - Parashat Termuah 5780, February 28, 2020

This week’s  parasha , Termuah, and next week’s parasha , Tetzave, introduce Hashem’s command regarding the plans for the  mishkan  and its vessels – including the clothing worn by the  kohanim . One of the vessels that Hashem commands to be built is the  menorah  – the candelabra. The description of the plans for the menorah are described in Parashat Terumah and the description of its service is described in Parashat Tetzave. In Parashat Tetzave, the Torah says, “and they will take for you pure olive oil pressed to be lit to raise an everlasting candle.” Each evening the  kohanim  were obligated to light the candelabra with enough oil to last the night. In the morning, the  kohanim  were obligated to fix and relight the  menorah , as necessary, thus ensuring that the candelabra would constantly be lit. The Rambam – Maimonides – explains, based on a later verse, that the  mitzvah  to light the candelabra in the mishk...

Learning Today, Leading Tomorrow - Rabbi Owen's Operational Dinner Remarks - Monday, September 17, 2018

You may have noticed that we have two new huge street-side banners on White Station Road. One of them says, “Learning Today, Leading Tomorrow”. What do we mean by this? How does learning prepare for leading? The distinctiveness and difference of the Jewish People is a theme that appears regularly and intensely throughout the Yom Kippur prayers. On Yom Kippur afternoon, we read the section of the Torah dealing with immorality. The Torah says, “Do not act in the ways of the land of Egypt in which you lived; and do not act in the ways of the land of Cana’an to which I, Hashem, am taking you – and do not follow their customs. Follow My laws and guard My customs to walk in these ways – I am Hashem your G-d.” The Torah is teaching that Egypt and Cana’an represent spiritually harmful elements of each culture in which the Jewish People will find themselves over the centuries and instructs us to separate from the temptation to assimilate these ideas. The Jewish People dwell alone. Hashe...

Building Appropriate Fences - Parashat Ki Seitzei 5778, August 24, 2018

Among the many mitzvot described in this week’s parasha , Parashat Ki Tetze, is the law of the ma’ake – a fence. “When you build a new house, you shall make a guard rail for your roof, so that you shall not cause blood to be spilled in your house, that the one who falls should fall from it.” In this verse, the Torah commands us to build a fence around any exposed high area, such as a flat roof or deck, that is commonly used by human beings. Viewing this law as a positive commandment, the Rambam teaches that one must make a blessing when constructing a ma’ake . The law of the ma’ake is one of many Torah laws that teach us to protect human life. Positive commandments such as ve’nishmartem me’od et nafshotechem (and you shall greatly guard your physical life) and ve’rapo yerape (and you shall surely heal) reveal the Torah’s appreciation of man’s vulnerability and the lengths that we must go to foster human safety. Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik extends this concept of bui...