Skip to main content

Promoting Justice through Litigant Participation - Parashat Mishpatim 5776 - February 5, 2016

Parashat Mishpatim continues the Torah’s presentation, which began in last week’s parasha, of the mitzvot that were revealed to b'nei yisrael at Mount Sinai.

One of the topics that is shared between the two parashiyot is the primacy of creating a judicial system with integrity. The Torah admonishes us not to testify as a group with evil people. The Torah admonishes judges to not show favoritism to a poor person. The Torah forbids judges to accept bribes.

In last week’s parasha, the Torah records Yitro’s suggestion of the four qualities that a judge should have: accomplished, G-d-fearing, committed to truth and money-despising. Basing himself on the Mechilta, Rashi elaborates on the quality of commitment to truth. Rashi explains that these are trust-worthy people, and that, because it is reasonable to rely on them generally, people will listen to the judgments that they render.

The first part of Rashi’s comment is easily understood – a judge must be trust-worthy. Trust-worthiness is a measure of a person’s commitment to truth. If a person says that he or she will do something and doesn’t do it, the value that that person places on truth is rightfully suspect. However, the second part of Rashi’s comment is more difficult to understand. It is correct that trust-worthiness will lead to compliance with a judge’s decisions but why should our selection of judges be guided by a concern over promoting compliance with a judge’s rulings? That task would seem to be better left to the police!

I am currently learning the third perek of Masechet Sanhedrin with my students in the Cooper Yeshiva High School for Boys. This chapter discusses the procedure for selecting a court when two litigants do not have access to courts of expert judges such as those that existed in the Land of Israel during the time of the Sanhedrin. The Mishna presents the procedure of zabla – an acronym for ze borer lo echad. According to the position of Rabbi Meir, each litigant chooses one judge to sit on a court and the two litigants then cooperate to select a third judge to sit in judgment with the first two. The gemara wonders why such a convoluted process is necessary – wouldn’t it be easier for the two parties to come to a consensus about which court to use to hear the case? The gemara explains that by constructing the court through the zabla procedure – each litigant first chooses a judge – truth will be achieved. Rashi explains the meaning of the gemara. Truth will be achieved because each litigant – even when found guilty – will be more likely to comply with the court’s ruling because he knows that the judge that he chose represented his claim as completely as possible. Since the judge that he chose was involved in the ruling, the ruling must be fair. The litigant will follow the court’s direction.

It appears from this gemara that the Torah is concerned not only with arriving at correct judgments but at creating a society that complies with justice. If judges make rulings and nobody listens, justice is hollow. If courts issue decisions and litigants complain, justice is eroded. A just society is the goal – not simply just decisions.

Perhaps this idea explains Rashi’s understanding that trust-worthiness is a necessary quality in a judge. A judge’s trust-worthiness will lead to compliance with the litigant’s rulings. When judges are trust-worthy, people will listen. When society listens to the decisions of judges, society is more just overall.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Meaning of the Shofar - Parashat Netzavim 5776 - September 30, 2016

In allusion to George Orwell: all of the passages in the Rambam’s magnum opus – the Mishne Torah – are meaningful; but some are more meaningful than others. One such passage in The Laws of Repentance (3:4) fits this description. Maimonides writes: Even though the sounding of the shofar on Rosh HaShanah is a decree, it contains an allusion. It is as if [the call of the shofar ] is saying: Wake up you sleepy ones from your sleep and you who slumber, arise. Inspect your deeds, repent, remember your Creator. Those who forget the truth in the vanities of time and throughout the entire year, devote their energies to vanity and emptiness which will not benefit or save: Look to your souls. Improve your ways and your deeds and let every one of you abandon his evil path and thoughts. Accordingly, throughout the entire year, a person should always look at himself as equally balanced between merit and sin and the world as equally balanced between merit and sin. If he performs one sin, he tips his...

Honor and Glory - Parashat Termuah 5780, February 28, 2020

This week’s  parasha , Termuah, and next week’s parasha , Tetzave, introduce Hashem’s command regarding the plans for the  mishkan  and its vessels – including the clothing worn by the  kohanim . One of the vessels that Hashem commands to be built is the  menorah  – the candelabra. The description of the plans for the menorah are described in Parashat Terumah and the description of its service is described in Parashat Tetzave. In Parashat Tetzave, the Torah says, “and they will take for you pure olive oil pressed to be lit to raise an everlasting candle.” Each evening the  kohanim  were obligated to light the candelabra with enough oil to last the night. In the morning, the  kohanim  were obligated to fix and relight the  menorah , as necessary, thus ensuring that the candelabra would constantly be lit. The Rambam – Maimonides – explains, based on a later verse, that the  mitzvah  to light the candelabra in the mishk...

Teaching Empathy - Parashat Ki Tetze - September 1, 2017

This week’s parasha , Ki Tetze, presents a summary of many of the mitzvot . In the last section of the parasha , the Torah recounts two sets of commandments. The first set discusses the just treatment of the downtrodden. The Torah writes, “You shall not pervert the judgment of a convert or orphan and you shall not take the garment of a widow as a pledge. You will remember that you were a slave in Egypt and Hashem, your G-d, redeemed you from there; therefore, I command you to do this thing.” The second set discusses the obligations of a harvester to the downtrodden. The Torah writes, “When you reap your harvest in your field, and you forget a bundle in the field, you shall not turn back to take it; it will be for the convert, the orphan and the widow, so that Hashem, your G-d, will bless you in all that you do. When you beat the olive tree, do not remove all the splendor behind you; it will be for the convert, the orphan and the widow. When you harvest your vineyard, you will not...